Why understanding your past hasn't made it hurt less

You can tell the whole story without your voice shaking. You know where it started and why it affected you the way it did, and you can probably connect it to how you show up at work or in relationships now. Maybe you've talked it through in therapy before, and it helped. And still, a certain tone of voice or a song playing in a store can drop you right back into it, and for a minute it feels like no time has passed at all.

If that sounds familiar, I want to say this first: you haven't done therapy wrong, and you're not failing at getting over it.

Insight matters, and it isn't always enough

I say this as a therapist who loves a good insight. Understanding why you react the way you do gives you options, and it can help you be a lot kinder to yourself. It's usually where the work starts. But I think a lot of us quietly expect that one more breakthrough moment will be the one that finally makes it stop hurting. Then it doesn't, and we figure we must be missing something.

Often, what's happening is that the part of you that understands and the part of you that reacts aren't working from the same file. Your thinking brain knows it's over. Your body may still be responding to what it learned back then, because some experiences get stored before your brain has a chance to fully process them. So the memory stays sharp and close, like it happened last week instead of years ago, and explaining it one more time doesn't seem to reach it.

That doesn't mean something is wrong with you, and it doesn't mean you're stuck forever. It just means understanding and healing can be two different kinds of work.

You haven't failed at therapy if understanding something hasn't made it hurt less.

Doing something differently

In a recent video I said you can't think your way into a different life if your behavior never changes. A lot of the time, that means practicing something new in your actual day, like setting the boundary or letting yourself rest without earning it first. With memories that still feel too close, doing something differently can also mean trying a different kind of therapy.

That's where EMDR comes in for a lot of the people I work with. EMDR stands for Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing, which is a mouthful, and I promise it's a lot less strange than it sounds. You hold a piece of a memory in mind while following bilateral stimulation, usually my hand moving back and forth or gentle tapping, and that can help your brain finish the processing it didn't get to do at the time.

You don't forget what happened, and it doesn't get erased. What tends to change is how it feels. People often describe it afterward as feeling further away, more like something that happened to them than something that's still happening. Talk therapy can be great for understanding why something affected you, and EMDR works on the part of you that understanding hasn't reached. If you're curious, you can read more on my EMDR therapy page.

Something gentle for the meantime

You don't need to work through anything on your own for this week to feel a little steadier. One small place to start is noticing when an old reaction shows up, without arguing with it. You might say to yourself, "That's an old feeling showing up in a new moment," and then bring your attention back to where you actually are.

It can also help to give your body some proof of the present. Letting your eyes land on what's really in the room, like the lamp in the corner or the dog asleep on the couch, can help your nervous system catch up to the fact that you're okay right now. Go slowly with it, and if anything feels like too much, you can always stop.

Try this tonight: Press your feet into the floor and let your eyes rest on what's in the room.

When it keeps coming back

If something from your past keeps showing up in your present, it may be that your brain filed it as unfinished and keeps bringing it back up to try to finish it. That makes sense, and it's something we can work on together at a pace that feels doable. I see clients in person in Southlake and online across Texas, and a free 15-minute consult is a low-pressure way to see whether EMDR feels like a fit.

Previous
Previous

When a feeling never got to finish